March 9, 2027 @ 9:00 am – 5:00 pm CST
Michael Ellis School for Dog Trainers, 3641 Stony Point Road, Santa Rosa, CA
Instructor: Dr. Stewart Hilliard
Pre-Event Overview
This “pre-event” is a crash course designed to prepare new Kynology students for the inaugural E-Collar Summit. Dr. Hilliard will cover the essential topics in aversive control, stress science, and animal welfare science, and introduce the Kynology Agency-Accountability Framework. After attending this course, students will have the necessary familiarity with the relevant behavioral science to follow all the discussions of e-collar theory and technique over the four days of the Summit.
Skip to Core Topics & Curriculum below.
Who Should Take This?

Pre-Event Curriculum (Core Topics & Conceptual Framework):
We’ll address head-on the controversies about aversive control, stress, animal welfare, and the ethics of aversive control in dog training. In particular we will examine how the use of positive punishment and negative reinforcement is compatible with dog welfare, provided that the training approach ensures that the canine learner has both predictability and control of aversive contingencies
- Defining aversive control: Is aversive control the use of “fear” in dog training? Is it instead using physical tools to limit the dog’s behavioral choice? Or is aversive control best defined functionally in terms of the use of negative reinforcement and/or positive punishment?
- Mechanisms of negative reinforcement and positive punishment, including the critical distinction between escape and avoidance, and the mechanisms of safety and cessation cues
- Aversive signaling: The roles of secondary negative reinforcers and secondary punishers in dog training.
- Theories of psychological stress, and the methodological difficulties of measuring stress; including the limitations of physiological measures such as blood concentrations of “stress” hormones. We will also consider emerging data and theories about “beneficial levels” of stress.
- Pavlovian conditioning and counterconditioning and how learning can change the emotional “valence” of stimuli (“bad” to “good,” or vice-versa)
- Evolving definitions of animal welfare, including discussion of sentience, moral standing, and ethics, with a focus on animal welfare as it is understood broadly in the welfare science community rather than narrowly in the dog training community
- The learned helplessness phenomenon and why dog welfare is not best defined in terms of the presence or absence of stress, but instead in terms of the dog’s ability to predict and control stress
- Conceptions of agency, including choice agency and operant agency, how they can be identified in dogs under training, and their usefulness in assessing if a dog training system best serves the welfare of the individual dog.
- Accountability– Is it best thought of as a behavioral standard applicable to an individual dog, as a “stage” of training, or as an ethical obligation of the guardian toward the dog and toward the community in which the guardian-dog dyad live?
- The Agency- Accountability Framework–How it provides tools to assess training methods for how well they safeguard welfare, for their ethical defensibility, and for their consistency with scientific data on animal learning and animal welfare
- A brief overview of the scientific references that bear directly on the subject of dog training, including the “famous 20” scientific papers that were used by the American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior to support their claim that use of aversive control is not justified under any circumstances.
Schedule:
Registration options
Seminar Participant (On-Site)
Virtual Participant (Livestream)
Can’t make it in person? Join us from anywhere! (Lectures and Discussions will be live-streamed).
Access to Recordings
Time zone, Job Responsibilities or Prior Commitments getting in your way? Due to popular request, we will be granting attendees access to recordings for a window of time after the event (one month, possibly longer) to catch up on anything missed due to dogs, jobs and that pesky need to sleep. We intend for this to be a LIVE event that encourages (and is influenced by!) remote participation (rather than paid access to videos on-demand), but also don’t want to exclude those of you who can join us for much but not all of the seminar.
Registration
The event will be live-streamed and all attendees, both live and virtual, will have limited access to recordings after the event. Virtual attendees will have the ability to submit comments and questions, which Dr. Hilliard will review and respond to those most relevant to the discussion on camera. —Note, e-collar summit attendees may mix and match virtual vs in-person attendance between the pre-event and main event.

